Re: Comments on fullscreen dialog

["Richard Bronosky" <mythtv bronosky com>]

On 4/5/07, Warren Baird <photogeekmtl gmail com> wrote:

Hi all,

With Stephene's help, I've managed to get the most recent svn build
working with my existing photo db.

So far my impressions of the changes over the last few months are
positive, except for the dialog that shows up in fullscreen mode when
you press a key or move the mouse.

I have basically 2 main use cases for full-screen mode:
    1: showing photos to people.   I rarely use slideshow mode for this,
because there's no pause, forward or back controls.

    2: reviewing photos - here I regularly use the forward and next keys
to move between photos, and quite often press '1' and scroll around in
full resolution mode to see how sharp the picture is.

In both of these modes, the current dialog is far more annoying than
useful   It's near the bottom 1/3 line of the photo, where a lot of
people say you should put the interesting things in your photo, and it's
  big, quite a bit larger vertically than it needs to be.

Having this big grey oblong rectangle on the screen while trying to view
or scroll around your photo, is really annoying.    I usually view my
photos on a laptop with only 1024x768 resolution --- I need every pixel
usable.

Some specific suggestions:

   1:  make the dialog much smaller.   Do you really need a drop-down to
select photo transitions on it?  Can't this be on the  preferences page?
  Can we trim the surrounding grey space?   Or make the window transparent?

   2: move it to a corner of the screen - it's far less likely to be in
the way there

   3: don't show it when a valid action key is pressed.   If I press the
'next' or 'previous' key --- you shouldn't pop up the dialog.

Amen!  If you  correctly request the performing of a valid action, you should not get interupted by an "idoit box".  That's a "very Microsoft Office" thing to do!  Clippy says, I see that you performed action X, but based on the stupidity of the average user I think you may mean to do one of V, W, X, Y, or Z.

  Also
don't show it when the mouse is moving with the mouse button pressed.
If I'm panning around a zoomed in picture, I don't want to see the dialog.

Amen!  When the user is doing something valid, respect their knowledge of what they want to do.

Normally I'd just put my code where my mouth is and submit a patch ---
but I've been really busy lately, and I'm not sure I'll have time to
look at the code...

I've found f-spot Extremely difficult to contribute to.  The community is not the problem.  But getting a development workflow established is absolute voodoo.  If you do manage to get setup to do any valid code changes, please share the how-to/caveats.

Warren
_______________________________________________
F-spot-list mailing list
F-spot-list gnome org
http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/f-spot-list

-- 
.!# RichardBronosky #!.